Best Latin american restaurant in Blue Point

Flavorful, Fresh, And Always Authentic—Central American Fusion At Its Best

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

APP: Platanos Maduro

Add Item

BEEF

Traditional seasoned Beef with onions and peppers

Add Item

BUFFALO CHICKEN

Handmade empanada filled with shredded chicken, buffalo sauce, and cheese, typically seasoned to achieve a balance of spicy and tangy flavors.

Add Item

BBQ Pulled pork

Shredded pork enveloped in a flaky pastry with BBQ sauce

Add Item

CHIFRIJO: Chicharron (Fried Pork Belly)

Add Item

Loaded Dog

Add Item

Welcome to Tico's Empanadas!

Welcome to Tico's Empanadas!
Located right in the heart of Blue Point, NY, Tico's Empanadas is the place where authentic Central American flavors meet traditional American cuisine. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a quick bite to go, we're here to serve up food that feels like home. With every bite, you’ll taste the care and tradition passed down through generations of home cooking.

Authenticity at Its Best

At Tico’s, we believe in keeping things full of flavor. Our menu is inspired in Central American tradition, proudly serving empanadas with a mix of traditional American touch. Each empanada is freshly prepared, just the way we’ve been making them for years—always fresh, always flavorful, and always ready to satisfy. It’s food made with you in mind, designed to bring a little bit of home to your plate.

Convenience That Works for You

Convenience That Works for You
Life can get busy, and we’re here to make things easier. Craving Tico’s but don’t have time to dine in? No problem! We offer both delivery and pickup options, so you can enjoy our food wherever you are. It’s simple, fast, and convenient—just the way it should be. Place your order online with a few taps, and let us take care of the rest
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

Central American Fusion, Made Fresh And Served With Heart

Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about

Planning An Event?

Planning An Event?
et Tico’s Empanadas bring the taste of Central America with American spice to your gathering! 🎉 Whether it’s a casual get-together, a corporate meeting, or a family celebration, our catering service delivers fresh, made-to-order empanadas and more. With a variety of flavors and options, we make it easy for you to serve something everyone will enjoy
Catering

Stop by Tico's Today

Stop by Tico's Today
Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite spot or visiting the area, we’d love to see you at Tico’s Empanadas. Stop by, order online, or grab some takeout today! Visit Us! 📌55 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715, United States

Featuring

Catering

Group Reservations and Private Parties

Easy Parking

Dine In

Takeout

Delivery

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

The food was great but the owners were even more amazing! They took the time to show our daughter how to make an empanada! Our girls loved the empanadas and the food here, if you have kids bring them over for a great time, you won’t regret it!

Paul L.

Paul L.

This place is the best!!! Great employees great atmosphere great food! I had the chicken teriyaki, beef and cheese, chicken cheese, flautas, tostones, chicken cheese with coleslaw !! Agua frescas were fantastic MENU IS HUGE AND DELICIOUS!! so happy with this place will definitely be back !! Thank you!! Hidden Gem !

Sophia P.

Sophia P.

There have been a lot of new empanada places opening in the general area lately but seriously, eat at Tico's. Super friendly owner and the food was just incredible. Everything, including the empanadas, is made fresh to order right in front of you. The tostone bowl was a new twist that I haven't seen anywhere else before and you could seriously put their Chimichuri on anything and it would be fantastic. This place is the real deal and a great addition to the area. Bonus that almost everything they make is naturally gluten free

Gary Z.

Gary Z.

Tico's Empanadas Rewards

Tico's Empanadas Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Frequently asked questions

Our location